As a family travel blogger I’ve been invited to enjoy quite a few unique experiences through my blog over the past few years.
Initially I have gone along to enjoy whatever is on offer, always excited to embrace the new opportunities that have come my way, but also happy to be able to educate my kids and share our amazing world with them….
Except over time I’ve come to realise that not all experiences are the same.
As a parent I love exposing my kids to new experiences and seeing and interacting with animals of any kind is obviously always very appealing to my kids…. all kids. But as I have had more opportunities, I’ve realised that some establishments are better than others… and it’s not always easy to know upfront what is appropriate when it comes to animal encounters.
With full disclosure I must say that I’ve sometimes found myself going along to various animals experiences and subsequently sharing them on my blog… but deep down I’ve not always been entirely sure whether they are “ok” or not!! It’s a really difficult question to ask, and even hard to answer, especially when you realise you may have been making some bad choices up until this point….
So, I decided to get a few people who are more knowledgeable in this area than I, to share their thoughts on the topic of The Ethics of Animal Encounters.
The main aim of this post is actually to educate myself, but I feel it will also help other families who enjoy traveling and exposing their kids to new experiences, on what is the best way to go about interacting with animals, if at all!
The questions I asked them were:
“What animal encounters (if any) are appropriate for both wild and domesticated animals?”
“What animal encounters would you say are inappropriate? eg. Game Drives, Petting Zoos, Animal Sanctuaries (no touching but rehabilitated animals behind bars), Elephant Encounters, Reptile Displays, Zoos, Breeding Programmes, Circuses etc”
“How would you suggest families distinguish for themselves about what animal encounters to support, and which to avoid?”
The experts I chatted to about The Ethics of Animal Encounters included an animal activist at a wildlife conservation organisation, a marketing manager for a well known animal sanctuary and travel journalist and a former tour operator now sustainable tourism consultant.
Here’s what the experts had to say about The Ethics of Animal Encounters…
Galen Schultz (Representative of Non-profit Conservation Organisation at WildlifeAct.com)
As a wildlife conservation organisation, Wildlife ACT are strictly against any interaction with wild animals by the public, even in some so-called sanctuaries.
There are many in South Africa that operate under the guise of conservation who are running very unethical operations. This is especially true of big cats where “sanctuaries” often claim that they will release them back into the wild, whereas the sad reality is that many of these are animals are sold and fuel things like trophy hunting and the tiger / lion bone trade. Cruelty to wild animals also exists in circuses, shark cage diving and riding elephants. All are advised against.
When it comes to sanctuaries caring for orphaned animals that cannot make it alone in the wild and have to be looked after their entire lives, then interaction is obviously necessary to feed and care for these orphans. However, such interactions should be limited to only what is necessary rather than be encouraged for profit. In some cases, injured or orphaned animals are successfully released back into the wild after rehabilitation and human care.
Most importantly is for members of the public to do some research into the places they wish to visit and only support those which are recommended by leading conservation authorities. There are some good campaigns and community groups on Facebook, such as Volunteers in Africa Beware, Blood Lions and the Born to be Wild campaign which are all good places to start when looking for projects to support and to better educate yourself on your animal encounter choices.
I spoke to Lara over the telephone to get some of her insights into this topic. Here’s what she had to say…
When it comes to responsible tourism there is no grey area. There is a right and a wrong way to interact with animals.
Wild animals are exactly that – wild. They should be free to roam the wild. Unfortunately there are now wild animals that are no longer born in the wild and don’t know how to survive in the wild should they find themselves back there. In that case there is a place for animal sanctuaries, but these should always be places that commit to giving these animals a “forever” home where they can live out the remainder of their lives. They should be actively trying to protect the animals and making the lives of animals in captivity better. This can be done by having less animals and more space in a better environment.
Animals in captivity should be put onto birth control (females) or sterilised (males) so that there is no risk of breeding more captive wild animals who can’t survive in the wild. Any organisation that breeds animals in captivity should be questioned. Many of these organisations, especially those breeding wild cats, are selling the cubs onto hunting programmes after they have served their time as petting cubs. Avoid all animal petting. All animal encounters should be “hands off”. Research ethical animal encounters online at ANVR. They list over 900 operators worldwide that have been vetted
There should be no animal ambassadors. Why is it fair that one animal has been pulled out of his family and environment to teach you about his breed. Are there human ambassadors – a short one, a tall one, a toddler one, a baby one, a Chinese one or a French one? No! There would be a massive outcry!
There should be no paid volunteer programmes for tourists, only qualified volunteers, such as zoologists, should be allowed to volunteer at these sanctuaries and then for a minimum period of 6 weeks with no touching of the animals whatsoever.
Animals should never be forced to touch you and should be allowed to roam freely. Touching humans is unnatural to animals and enticing animals to touch you through hand feeding is unethical. If they choose to come up to you and touch you on their own terms then there is nothing you can do, but you can also actively discourage animals from touching you (eg. squirt monkeys with a water bottle) Touching wild animals such as monkeys can actually be harmful to them and vice versa. Diseases such as lip herpes are in fact deadly to certain species of monkeys. A huge problem these days is the “Animal Selfie” culture. No one should take a selfie with an animal by forcing the animal to be in the picture with you – these are disrespectful to the animals and every tourist that poses with an animal perpetuates the problem by encouraging others to do the same for the social media glory.
Although there is a place for zoos in the world as some of the best breeding programmes have seen vulnerable species revived (eg. the panda) it’s best to avoid zoos and all circuses that feature animal acts as very few do the right thing.
Basically the bottom line is that it’s best to avoid animal interactions that include walking with animals or riding of animals (eg elephants) these include swimming with dolphins or watching dolphin shows and operations that use chumming to lure sharks for shark cage diving.
It goes without saying that no wild animals should ever be kept as pets!
Linda Markovina (Travel writer and Photojournalist for Moving Sushi)
When it comes to getting your kids excited about the natural world out there I would always suggest that they develop this through programs and initiatives that know what they are doing and adhere to strict levels of animal care. The first thing they need to learn is that animals, even domestic ones, should interact with us on their terms. It is not about our own fulfillment, but about being able to have an experience that will leave a lasting impression without doing damage. It is also about teaching them that the emotions we experience as human beings are not necessarily the same emotions that an animal (domestic or wild) experiences, so getting them to learn that, say a dog doesn’t like to be squeezed to death or an elephant does not like to be ridden, are one in the same to me. Thats starts by showing kids how to navigate nature and how to understand and observe different animal behaviour. Aim to create mini-ecologists and scientists with a good base!
Appropriate animal encounters are anything that fosters a exploration of the natural world. For example learning to free dive so that you can venture out safely into the ocean and discover what is beneath the waves, and when you have an encounter with say a fish or a dolphin or even a whale, if you are lucky enough, it is in the animals realm and on their terms. They come to you, you don’t touch and you just observe. Same with animals on land. They learn about the natural environment and how to move, live and exist in it through programs like Bush guides or anything that gets kids outdoors and learning about nature (plants , bugs etc.) and then how the animals live in that environment and how we interact with them. Again, no touching or chasing, just experiencing being in the same space as the animals. Game drives in a reputable reserve are a great place to start.
I am very much against circuses, breeding programs, elephant encounter, and zoos. Seeing an animal in a zoo is not educating kids, they just get to look at an animal behind glass or cages and that doesn’t foster any kind of good relationship between a child, the animal and it’s environment.
One place that does get it right for me is the Two Oceans Aquarium (not Ushaka because of their dolphin show program) A lot of the creatures at Two Oceans are being rehabilitated but you don’t touch, and through their programs they foster this understanding and connection with the ocean without exploiting the situation. Watamu Turtle Watch in Kenya also has great program for kids, educating them inside their rehabilitation centre and through things like mangrove walks and beach clean ups. A general rule is that if an establishment is doing any “walking with”, “swim with” or breeding programs I would see a red flag and steer far away. No petting whatsoever.
Louise de Waal (Sustainable Tourism Consultant at Green Girls in Africa)
My stance is very one-dimensional because I believe we need to convey a clear and transparent message about interactions with wildlife in captivity to rid our industry from the ambiguity around animal encounters.
Awareness and education is the first and most important step towards making more responsible choices. As more people become conscious of the ethics of wildlife held in captivity, small ripples will be created adding to a global shift towards a more responsible tourism industry.
Before we decide what activities would be appropriate for wildlife and/or domesticated animals, I believe we need to consider the Five Freedoms Concept that was developed for the welfare of domestic farm animals and is used in animal welfare issues worldwide.
These Five Freedoms should always be applied when considering any animal interaction with either wild or domestic animals. If these Five Freedoms are not observed and you feel the animals are under unnecessary stress or pain, we should doubt the integrity and ethics of the facility and ask appropriate questions.
The Five Freedoms for Animals (both domestic and wild)
- Freedom from hunger or thirst by ready access to fresh water and a diet to maintain full health and vigour
- Freedom from discomfort by providing an appropriate environment including shelter and a comfortable resting area
- Freedom from pain, injury or disease by prevention or rapid diagnosis and treatment
- Freedom to express (most) normal behaviour by providing sufficient space, proper facilities and company of the animal’s own kind
- Freedom from fear and distress by ensuring conditions and treatment which avoid mental suffering
There are some very clear examples of animal encounters that should be avoided at all cost. All aspects of the despicable canned lion hunting industry, which includes a chain of money making businesses starting with captive lion breeders, lion cub petting and walking with lion facilities, certain volunteering organisations, and ends with canned hunting farms. Organisations such as SeaWorld have been heavily criticised for their lack of care and cruelty to the captive and trained dolphins and orcas. Many of the dolphins and orcas are captured from the wild and lead lonely lives in captivity, in restricted and unhealthy conditions. All elephant back riding is unacceptable with no exceptions. These are some extreme cases of animal exploitation and even cruelty, purely for the sake of our entertainment. Solely so that we can experience these magnificent animals up-close, take sensational photos, and share them with our friends on social media platforms.
However, many people may understand that for example elephant riding is off-bounds, but is walking with these iconic animals while holding their truck OK? Lion cub petting may now be considered as unethical, but do we allow walking with that one cheetah on a lead, since it is an ambassador for its species? Where do we draw the line of what is and is not acceptable? What is and is not ethical? What are the 50 shades of grey (or rather green) between black and white?
Unfortunately, our wildlife is unable to stand up for themselves, so we have to give them a voice and it is time for that voice to communicate a very clear and transparent message. A message that makes choices for tourists easy in terms of doing the right thing when it comes to animal and wildlife related activities.
All over the world, a wide range of wildlife has regrettably ended up in captivity for a variety of reasons and most cannot be returned to the wild. Animal encounters play a hugely important role in providing a forever home for these animals and these facilities need to create an income from those animals in order to keep them safe and healthy. However, the economic gain should never impact on the intrinsic rights of animals in captivity, such as the right to live without fear or pain, to have proper shelter, food and nourishment, to act according to their natural instincts, and to have freedom of movement.
Tips on choosing ethical animal encounters
- Any hands-off animal encounter benefiting both the wildlife and the visiting public and at the same time is a wonderful educational tool for children is one that I fully endorse. Sanctuaries such as Monkeyland, Birds of Eden, Jukani and Panthera Africa are all wonderful examples of a complete win-win situation.
- Game drives are a perfect activity for wildlife, so people can observe the animals in their natural habitat going about their daily activities. The downside is that not all game reserves allow younger children.
- Petting zoos should only be allowed for domestic animals and, even then, we need to make sure that the animals get regular breaks from the interactions or have human-free areas to escape to, have appropriate housing, and are fed and cared for properly.
- Animal sanctuaries – both wildlife and domestic animals, as long as there is no breeding and no touching. Facilities that offer touching of ANY kind and/or breed are not sanctuaries and their intensions should be questioned. It is also extremely important that the enclosures are appropriate to the species housed and that it offers enrichment activities.
- Elephant encounters and elephant interactions are not ideal as these magnificent animals should rather be enjoyed in the wild and from afar, where they can roam freely and live in their social groups as nature intended. See also: The Elephant in the Room
- Circuses that have shows involving any kind of animals, both wild or domesticated, are institutions where animals have no say in the matter while being trained therefore refer to the Five Freedoms listed above!
- Although many zoos contribute positively to research and safeguarding wildlife gene pools, and treat their animals well by moving away from cages and introducing more appropriate enclosures with enrichment activities, there are unfortunately many zoos around the world that happily offer less ethical activities. People should always be mindful and trust their instincts.
Many thanks to Galen, Louise, Lara and Linda for taking the time to share their valuable input on this senstive subject. I certainly feel more enlightened and I hope I have encouraged even just a few of my readers to think twice before paying to pet an animal in the future.
Images: Kathryn Rossiter